The anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is a critical component of the knee joint, providing stability and support during physical activities. An ACL rupture, often resulting from high-impact sports or accidents, can be a devastating injury that affects not only athletic performance but also daily life.
Traditionally, surgical intervention has been the go-to solution for treating these injuries, especially among athletes eager to return to their previous level of activity. However, growing evidence suggests that conservative management—encompassing a range of non-surgical options—can be a viable alternative for many patients.
This approach, which includes physical therapy, activity modification, and bracing, aims to restore knee function and facilitate a return to normal life without the risks and recovery time associated with surgery.
Who is a candidate for conservative management?
Conservative management for cruciate ligament injuries is often considered for individuals who:
- Have partial ACL tears.
- Have lower activity levels or do not participate in high-impact or pivoting sports.
- They do not experience significant "giving way" or instability in their knee during daily activities.
- Have medical conditions that make surgery risky.
- Are willing to commit to a rigorous and prolonged rehabilitation program.
- Show signs of coping in response to a three month rehabilitation program
Key Components of conservative management for anterior cruciate ligament ruptures
1. Initial pain and swelling management
-
RICE protocol: Rest, ice, compression, and elevation immediately after the injury helps reduce pain and swelling.
- Joint aspiration: In some cases, a doctor may remove fluid from the knee to relieve pain and swelling.
2. Physical therapy and rehabilitation
This is the cornerstone of conservative management and is highly individualised. A structured physical therapy program typically progresses through several phases:
Phase 1: Acute recovery phase
Focuses on reducing pain and swelling, restoring full range of motion (ROM), and activating the quadriceps muscle.
-
Exercises: Passive heel slides, prone hangs, ankle pumps, quadriceps sets (isometric contractions).
- Techniques: Cryotherapy and compression, neuromuscular electrical stimulation (NMES) for quadriceps activation.
Phase 2: Neuromuscular training and strength building
Aims to improve muscle strength around the knee, enhance stability, and retrain proprioception (the sense of joint position and movement).
-
Strengthening exercises: Hamstring curls, unilateral strengthening (single-leg step-ups, lunges), progressive weight-bearing exercises (mini-squats, leg presses, wall slides, bridging, calf raises).
- Balance and proprioceptive exercises: Single-leg stances, perturbation training (balance tasks on unstable surfaces like rocker boards).
Phase 3: Sport-specific training
For individuals aiming to return to higher-level activities, this phase involves drills that simulate movements required for their specific sport or activity.
-
Agility drills: High-speed cutting, pivoting, lateral shuffles.
-
Plyometrics: Box jumps, bounding, explosive movements.
- Sport-specific tasks: Integrating drills that mimic game-like conditions.
4. Bracing
A hinged knee brace or functional sports knee brace may be recommended to provide support, stability and allow the ACL to heal in the early stages of your recovery.
5. Activity modification
Avoiding high-impact activities that could worsen the injury is crucial. Patients are often encouraged to engage in low-impact exercises like swimming or cycling to maintain fitness. Ultimately, your therapist will guide you on modifications based on your individual needs.
6. Patient education
Understanding the injury, how to prevent instability, and adhering to the rehabilitation program are vital for successful conservative management.
Long-term outcomes of conservative management for anterior cruciate ligament ruptures
Recent research suggests that for certain patients, conservative management can lead to outcomes similar to surgical reconstruction in terms of knee function and return to sport. Some studies indicate lower reinjury rates and higher quality of life scores with conservative management compared to surgery, though these differences may not always be statistically significant.
However, conservative management may require lifestyle modifications, and there is a risk of persistent knee instability or further injury if the knee remains unstable. The development of osteoarthritis is a long-term concern with both surgical and conservative approaches, and research on this aspect is ongoing.
Ultimately, the decision between conservative and surgical management for an ACL rupture is highly individualised and depends on factors such as the severity of the tear, the patient's age, activity level, overall health, and long-term functional goals. A thorough discussion with an orthopedic surgeon and physical therapist is essential to determine the most appropriate treatment plan.
Final thoughts
Conservative management of an anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture refers to non-surgical treatment options aimed at restoring knee function, stability, and strength. While ACL tears are common, especially among athletes, surgery is not always the only or best option for every individual.
Every patient who sustains an ACL rupture should be provided with the opportunity and time to complete a pre-operative rehabilitation program, ideally for three months, with the opportunity to delay surgery based on criteria-driven results.
Book an appointment with one of our highly qualified physiotherapists at Enhance Physio before starting a rehabilitation program. We can advise you on the best course of action for your condition.
